Thursday, February 28, 2008

If America Got it Right Vol. II

This week, the fellas totally out sang the ladies. Not one of the ladies stood out last night; they were all just, meh (The only thing that stood out was the fact that Carley Smithson works at one of the best bars in San Diego and probably served me a Guinness at some point (and I'm almost positive she was singing when when Liz celebrated her birthday there last year). Makes me thirsty just thinking about it). Anyway, here's who should be sent home this week:

The Fellas
Luke Menard - He made it through last week, but really needs to go home now. His homage to Freddie Mercury was dreadful.

Jason Yeager - He seems like a swell guy and I even really like his voice, but there's no way he's winning this thing so he might as well go home now.

On Notice - Chikezie and Robbie Carrico (rocker, my ass)

The Ladies

Kady Malloy
- She'll might be safe because people love her Britney impersonation, but her voice isn't good enough (btw...does anyone else think she looks like Scarlett Johansson?)

Kristy Lee Cook - She was better this week, but still, not that great. And I think she has less potential than some of the other not so great singers this week.

On Notice - Alania Whitaker and Syesha Mercado (who is a great singer, but comes across so bitchy and entitled in her interviews)

Also, I think Amanda Overmyer had the worst vocal of the week, but she is interesting enough to garner the votes to keep her safe. She does need to sing something more relevant (as the judges would say) or she's bound to be sent packing (though, the odds of her winning it all are so small. Who would buy that record? The same people who bought Taylor Hicks album. Also known as, No One).

Finally, Best Vocal of the Week goes to David Archuleta with Imagine. I'm not gonna say I cried like a baby as Paula did, but it was pretty effing great.

Until next week!


BeckEye said...

If they ever got rid of two cutesy blonde girls at once, the fabric of the Idol universe would unravel.

I can't believe Luke didn't get cut last week. He is so pitifully boring. Must be the perfect teeth keeping the tweeners voting for him.

Red said...

You are so right, but I can dream...

It's def his looks. Paula put him through so she can flirt inappropriately with him until he is sent packing.

Falwless said...

Okay, I'm gonna disagree. And in writing, so you can say I was right when I am proven right. HA! Going home will will be Amanda and Kady, Chikezie and Robbie. Let thy will be done. Amen.

P.S. Amanda has got to go or I might lose my shit.

Falwless said...

Okay, um, scratch that crap up there. Going home will be........*DRUMROLL*...... Robbie, Jason, Alaina and Alexandréa!

Just, um, had a change of heart prediction-wise.

Red said...

So, did you lose your shit?

These things are so unpredictable. That's why I say who I think "should" go home, not who will...

Falwless said...

Nah, I didn't lose it. Frighteningly close.